How to write an unforgettable villain


Darth Vader.

Heath Ledger Joker.

Matt Damon in Interstellar.

What makes an unforgettable villain? And why are they so dang rare?

According to Nick Bilton, best-selling author of American Kingpin — a book about the literal creator of the Silk Road, an anonymous Dark Web marketplace for illegal drugs and contraband (talk about bad guys)…

“You can’t create monsters without NUANCE.”

Nuance is the elixir of evil.

Anakin:

  • Betrays his best friend
  • Kills younglings
  • Murders Padme

And yet…

You kinda…

Get it?

He got tricked by Palps!

He didn’t know any better…

C’mon, man!

Would you NOT turn to the dark side?

If it meant you could SAVE your loved one’s life from certain death?

(Is a blue lightsaber really that important to you???)

That’s called nuance.

And it’s how you write magnetic bad guys.

Imagine if the Joker was just a goofy terrorist with makeup.

“HAHAHAheheHoohooHAHA… I’m going to blow up this hospital because I FEEL like it!”

*yawn*

But, what if…

“I’m going to blow up this hospital… IF you don’t kill this guy who just threatened to reveal Batman’s identity on live television… within 60 minutes.”

Woah woah woah…

Is Joker lowkey a bro?

Sure, he’s blowing up a hospital…

Buuuuuuut…

He’s also protecting Batman!

Nuance.

Nuance is the antidote to boredom…

And in the game of writing, boredom is enemy #1.

So the question is…

How do you create nuance?

Well, it’s simpler than you might think (but that doesn’t mean it’s EASY)…

In the words of The Big Short Screenwriter (I can’t remember if it’s Adam McKay or Charles Randolph who said it, so forgive me – it’s one of them)...

“You can’t look DOWN at your characters, you have to look at them – WITH them.”

Amateur writers:

  • Judge their characters
  • Force their viewpoints onto the audience
  • Don't allow them to come to their own conclusions.

Pro writers know...

Every bad guy — yes, even the Voldemorts and Lord Farquads of the world — are the heroes of their own story.

So you have to climb inside their head.

Look at the world through their eyes.

And ask:

“Why do I do what you do?”

You don't have to like the answer.

You just have to be honest about what their "why" is...

And then give your audience the chance to decide for themselves.

Nuance.

Remember Matt Damon in Interstellar?

  • Lies about his data
  • Tries to murder Cooper
  • Attempts to abandon the Endurance crew

He’s TERRIBLE!

But somehow…

You kinda…

Feel for the guy?

He’s been stranded out there for 30 YEARS, on a mission to literally save humanity — and this pretty boy slick talkin’ bozo from Texas comes in, says “F the mission”, and attempts to take his ship back home just so he can say “sowwy” to his kids.?

I’d lie… attempt 1st degree murder… and steal Cooper’s ship, too!

…or would I?

THAT’S nuance, baby.

-Sven “Nuance is the antidote to boredom” Slattum

P.S. It’s time to vote on next week’s topic. Your fellow AI-FREE Writers Club members have been sending me secrets all week. These are my 3 favorites. Now, the fate of next week's correspondence lies in your hands...

As always — If you have a writing secret to share with the club, send it to my email: sven@aifreewritersclub.com

I will pick my favorites, and then put them in next week’s poll.

If your secret wins the vote?

  • I’ll send you a free AI-FREE Writers Club hat
  • You’ll get a free shoutout and/or advertising for whatever writing project (or non-writing project) you’re working on right now
  • And your name will go on the AI-FREE Writers Club Wall of Fame… FOREVER.

Talk to you next Friday.

Write on!

The AI-FREE Writers Club

If you love writing (and hate AI slop), join the club ✍️⬇️

Read more from The AI-FREE Writers Club

I watched Inception about 37 times as a kid. This was my first time watching it as an adult. When you’re a kid, you think it’s about dreams. When you’re an adult, you realize it’s about writing. Writing is inception. Inception: The art of planting ideas in someone else’s mind. Sound familiar? Screenwriting: The art of planting an idea in someone else’s mind in a way that entertains and moves them emotionally. Copywriting: The art of planting an idea in someone else’s mind in a way that gets...

Today’s writing secret comes from a famous British ad writer by the name of Harry Dry. He’s got: A skin-tight buzz cut Wears wiry 70s style glasses Sounds like he could be a House DJ So? He was born to be a copywriter. And whenever he writes any ad, Harry asks himself 3 simple questions (and if you want to make British DJ type money with your ads, then I suggest you do the same.) Question #1: Can I visualize it? Great copy creates a mental image. If you can’t picture it, it’s too abstract… “1...

Hi Reader, I’m back with another juicy secret from one of your fellow AI-FREE Writers Club members. This one comes from a kick*ss copywriter (who chose to remain anonymous.) He learned this secret from one of the greatest musical writers to ever live. Legend has it… This composer wrote entire musical masterpieces... ...perfectly... on his first draft... With ZERO rewrites. How? With a simple, yet powerful writing technique I like to call: Mozart’s pool ball trick First, a little background on...